"Acceptance by the medical community is not a substitute for rigorous testing" TESTIMONY OF JOHN M. FRIEDBERG, M.D., NEUROLOGIST, BEFORE THE MENTAL HEALTH COMMITTEE OF THE NEW YORK STATE ASSEMBLY
"Sympathectomy is a technique about which we have limited knowledge, applied to disorders about which we have little understanding." Associate Professor Robert Boas, Faculty of Pain Medicine of the Australasian College of Anaesthetists and the Royal College of Anaesthetists
decreased brain metabolism, rather than an increased intracranial pressure, is the cause of decreased cerebral blood flow after superior cervical sympathetic ganglionectomy
CERVICAL SYMPATHECTOMY AND CEREBROSPINAL FLUID PRESSURE: THEIR RELATIONSHIP TO BRAIN METABOLISM
Surgical Denervation of Ocular Sympathetic Afferents Decreases Local Transforming Growth Factor-β and Abolishes Immune Privilege
Cervical sympathectomy causes photoreceptor-specific cell death in the rat retina
Volume 120, Issues 1-2, 15 June 2005, Pages 46-51
morphological changes in the retina noted after sympathectomy
Secondary Effects of Sympathectomy - Disturbance of Sexual Function
We disagree that surgery and botulinum toxin are treatments of choice in severe cases of hyperhidrosis
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1118569/
Iontophoresis should be tried before other treatments
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1118569/
the Kuntz nerve played no part in the success or failure of ETS surgery
about the importance or otherwise of the Kuntz nerve. The Kuntz nerve is a small nerve
fibre sometimes seen on the second rib not far from the main sympathetic chain. Its
function is not known in humans. Some web-sites on ETS claim success rates of up to
100% for facial blushing because they search for and destroy the Kuntz nerve(s). These
same people also claim to be able to correct failed ETS operations by reoperating and
destroying the Kuntz nerve.
At the meeting of the International Society for Sympathetic Surgery in Germany, May
2003, attended by a majority of the world’s experts in ETS surgery (including us), all but
one of the surgeons present were of the opinion that the Kuntz nerve played no part in the
success or failure of ETS surgery for facial blushing. We share this majority opinion.
www.lapsurgeryaustralia.com.au
Fake websites in the service of the ETS industry - who protects the patients?
Many surgeons compete with each other for the attention of the 'costumer' in the saturated market of the www. Adaptations to a business model raises ethical questions that should have been explored long ago and should have raised the ire of the medical community. The occasional whimper of discord is silenced by the cacophony of (ignorant) enthusiasm. Not quite the scientific behavior one would expect.
How does the entrepreneurial aspect of medicine impact on the information patients are given? In the area of elective procedures, is it in the interest of the service provider to provide full disclosure? Does self-interest influence and modify how the information is conveyed? How information morphs into little facts and more emoting, to appeal to the irrational in all of us, to seduce us.
Fake websites that pretend to be independent, informative, with the sole raison d'etre to praise the surgeon's skill, expertise and experience, - and to hook the patient into reading more on the surgeons' website, with many obvious links to the surgeon on every page.
Why are predatory practices of medical professionals tolerated?
In 70 % compensatory sweating severe, recurrence rates were 15% and 19% at 1 and 2 years after surgery
In T2 resection, recurrence rates were 15% and 19% at 1 and 2 years after surgery.It was not rare for a patient to experience recurrence more than 3 years after surgery.
Motoki Yano, MD, PhD and Yoshitaka Fujii, MD, PhD
Volume 138, Issue 1, Pages 40-45 (July 2005)
The results of endoscopic sympathectomy deteriorate progressively from the immediate outcome
1999, vol. 86, no1, pp. 45-47 (12 ref.)
a strong association of autonomic dysfunction and impaired cerebral autoregulation
Drug and Alcohol Dependence
Volume 110, Issue 3, 1 August 2010, Pages 240-246
After sympathectomy for hyperhidrosis, very severe discomfort and hyperhidrosis occurred with alarming frequency and intensity
"After thoracoscopic sympathectomy for hyperhidrosis, very severe discomfort and hyperhidrosis in the neighboring non-sympathectomized regions occurred with alarming frequency and intensity."
(p.879)
Cousins and Bridenbaugh's Neural Blockade in Clinical Anesthesia and Pain Medicine by Michael J Cousins, Phillip O Bridenbaugh, Daniel B Carr, and Terese T HorlockerWolters Kluwer Health
Edition: 4 - 2008
Sympathectomy is one of the causes or Orthostatic Hypotension
Causes of Orthostatic Hypotension
Peripheral
Amyloidosis
Diabetic, alcoholic, or nutritional neuropathy
Familial dysautonomia (Riley-Day syndrome)
Guillain-Barré syndrome
Paraneoplastic syndromes
Pure autonomic failure (formerly called idiopathic orthostatic hypotension)
Surgical sympathectomy
http://www.merckmanuals.com/professional/sec07/ch069/ch069d.htmlcervical ganglionectomy produces a significant reduction in the noradrenergic innervation of ip- silateral extraparenchymal arteries
for the presence of noradrenergic fibers. The results of the study demonstrate that:
(1) superior cervical ganglionectomy produces a significant reduction in the noradrenergic innervation of ipsilateral extraparenchymal arteries;
(2) the peripheral sympathetic nervous system contributes to overall cerebral vascular resistance primarily by affecting resistance in extraparenchymal arteries; and
(3) as a result, it determines the contribution of the extraparenchymal arteries tooverall cerebral blood flow autoregulation.
1975;6;284-292 Stroke
interrupting sympathetic efferent fibers innervating the heart and baroreflex
Baroreflex control of heart rate during cardiac sympathectomy by epidural anesthesia in lightly anesthetized humans.
Dohi S, Tsuchida H, Mayumi T
Anesth Analg 1983; 62:815-20.
Baroreflex sensitivity, measured as cardiac acceleration in response to nitroglycerin, was significantly lower (p < style="font-weight: bold;">The results suggest that baroreflex-mediated response to decreases in arterial pressure is dependent on the integrity of the sympathetic nervous system.
Baroreflex control of heart rate during high thoracic epidural anaesthesia. A randomised clinical trial on anaesthetised humans.
Goertz A, Heinrich H, Seeling W
Anaesthesia 1992; 47:984-7.
Other causes of autonomic dysfunction: sympathectomy
The finger wrinkling response is abolished by upper thoracic sympathectomy. The test is also abnormal in some patients with diabetic autonomic dysfunction, the Guillan-Barre syndrome and other peripheral sympathetic dysfunction in limbs. (p.46)
Other causes of autonomic dysfunction without neurological signs include medications, acute autonomic failure, endocrine disease, surgical sympathectomy . (p.100)
Anhidrosis is the usual effect of destruction of sympathetic supply to the face. However about 35% of patients with sympathetic devervation of the face, acessory fibres (reaching the face through the trigeminal system) become hyperactive and hyperhidrosis occurs, occasionally causing the interesting phenomenon of alternating hyperhidrosis and Horner's Syndrome (Ottomo and Heimburger, 1980). (p.159)
bradycardia and other cardiac complications are common side effects?
http://tipbilimleri.turkiyeklinikleri.com/abstract_54802.html
"It is a lie that sympatholysis may specifically cure patients
...it is not an error. but a lie. While conceptual errors are not only forgivable, but natural to inexact medical science, lies, particularly when entrepreneurially inspired are condemnable and call for a peer intervention.
J. Neurology (1999) 246: 875-879
Lack of disclosure to ETS patients is unethical and would be criminal in a just society
Although it is not possible to predict exactly what will occur in each individual case, there is nearly 100 years of published scientific and medical research available on the effects of sympathectomy. That research paints a very different picture of the effects of this surgery than the one presented to patients considering this surgery. That's the issue. Generally, they lie and tell patients that CS is inconsequential in all but a tiny fraction of cases and simply fail to disclose a huge number of verified adverse effects of the surgery. They take advantage of the patient's ignorance on medical matter. It's unethical and would be criminal in a just society.
In short, you do have a way of knowing what will likely occur as a result of the surgery before you have it done. All the information necessary to make an informed decision exists. It's just not getting to patients.
http://etsandreversals.yuku.com/reply/22927/Would-you-do-it-again#reply-22927
Surgical sympathectomy listed as neurologic disorder
- Idiopathic orthostatic hypotension
- Multiple sclerosis
- Parkinsonism
- Posterior fossa tumor
- Shy-Drager syndrome
- Spinal cord injury with paraplegia
- Surgical sympathectomy
- Syringomyelia
- Syringobulbia
- Tabes dorsales (syphillis)
- Wernicke's encephalopathy
Dizziness: Classification and Pathophysiology
The Journal of Manual and Manipulative Therapy, Vol. 12, No 4 (2004)
Sympathectomy induces adrenergic excitability of cutaneous C-fiber nociceptors
nerve damage causes an inflammatory response
eicosanoids; these mediators may contribute to the hyperalgesia which results from nerve injury. The cell types most likely to be responsible include macrophages and postganglionic sympathetic neurones.
http://www.springerlink.com/content/pjh3832058475340/
D. J. Tracey1 J. S. Walker1
School of Anatomy, University of New South Wales, 2052 Sydney, NSW, Australia
The brain and the immune system are the two major adaptive systems of the body. During an immune response the brain and the immune system “talk to each other” and this process is essential for maintaining homeostasis. Two major pathway systems are involved in this cross-talk: the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis and the sympathetic nervous system (SNS). This overview focuses on the role of SNS in neuroimmune interactions, an area that has received much less attention than the role of HPA axis. Evidence accumulated over the last 20 years suggests that norepinephrine (NE) fulfills the criteria for neurotransmitter/neuromodulator in lymphoid organs.
http://pharmrev.aspetjournals.org/content/52/4/595.abstract
82.9% Were Disturbed Because CS Was More Than Expected
Endoscopic thoracic sympathectomy (ETS) for palmar hyperhidrosis was performed using a 3-mm small endoscope at our hospital, and we conducted a questionnaire for the purpose of studying the conditions and satisfaction after surgery. The subjects were comprised of 50 patients, of which 35 patients (75%) answered the survey. The average age of the respondents was 27 years old (range: 12?62 years old) including 13 males and 22 females and the average postoperative observation period was 33 months (1?114 months). The results showed the good effects of surgery in all of the patients for palmar sweating while patient satisfaction was 79.4 points, which concluded that ETS was sufficiently accepted as treatment for palmar hyperhidrosis. However, compensatory sweating (CS) developed in 97.1% of the patients, and 82.9% answered that they were disturbed because it was more than they had expected. This result makes us realize further the importance of preoperative informed consent for CS. The problem of palmar hyperhidrosis is very serious for patients, and hence it is important to give treatment with a thorough understanding of the effectiveness and problems of ETS for palmar hyperhidrosis according to the analytical results of this questionnaire.
Safety and Ethics in Healthcare
"...professionals may adopt unreasonable practices. Practices may develop in professions, particularly as to disclosure, not because they serve the interests of the clients, but because they protect the interests or convenience of members of the profession. The court has an obligation to scrutinize professional practices to ensure that they accord with the standard of reasonableness imposed by the law."
Incresingly, the question is not whether the defendant's conduct conforms with the practices of the profession, but whether it conforms with standards of reasonableness. (p. 150)
"The right of patients self-determination is well entrenched both in law and in ethical codes. Respect for patient autonomy now occupies centre stage in medical ethics. In considering patient autonomy one needs to think about truth telling, confidentiality, privacy, disclosure of information and consent. Each is important and all have important implications for healthcare professionals." (p. 167)
Safety and Ethics in Healthcare: A Guide to Getting it Right, By Bill Runciman, Alan Merry
Published by Ashgate Publishing, Ltd., 2007
Effect of cervical sympathectomy and circulatory hypoxia on time course of prostaglandin concentration in brain tissues
http://www.springerlink.c...ontent/j705306763158841/
Some workers suggest a possible "transmembrane" role of PG in the nervous system.
If the increase in the PG level during ischemia is regarded as a protective reaction, it must be admitted that no increase took place 1 day after CSE (cervical sympathectomy) and it was considerably weakened 7-40 days after CSE.
The effect of cerebral ischemia was virtually indistinguishable from the action of CSE itself.
It can be tentatively suggested that PGF plays the main role in the regulation of tone of the vascular wall and in the regulation of metabolism under conditions of ischemia when the sympathetic regulation is disturbed.
sympathectomy-induced alterations of immunity
Many studies have demonstrated that ablation of the sympathetic nervous system (SNS) alters subsequent immune responses. Researchers have presumed that the altered immune responses are predominantly the result of the peripheral phenomenon of denervation. We, however, hypothesized that chemical sympathectomy will signal and activate the central nervous
system (CNS). Activation of the CNS was determined by immunocytochemical visualization of Fos protein in brains from male C57BL/6 mice at 8, 24, and 48 h following denervation. A dramatic induction of Fos protein was found in the paraventricular nucleus (PVN) of
the hypothalamus and other specific brain regions at 8 and 24 h compared
to vehicle control mice. Dual-antigen labeling demonstrates that corticotrophin releasing factor (CRF)-containing neurons in the PVN are activated by chemical sympathectomy; however, neurons containing neurotransmitters which may modulate CRF neurons, such as vasopressin,
tyrosine hydroxylase, and adrenocorticotropin, do not coexpress Fos. Our findings suggest an involvement of the CNS in sympathectomy-induced alterations of immunity.
Central Nervous System Activation following PeripheralChemical Sympathectomy: Implications for Neural–Immune Interactions
Brain, Behavior, and Immunity
Volume 12, Issue 3, September 1998, Pages 230-241
Effects of Sympathectomy on Muscle
an increase in cell size. There was a reduction in the proportion of slow myosin light chain isoforms from 50 ± 7 to 34 ± 6%. Noradrenaline levels were increased on the denervated sides but this may reflect greater vascularity. Calcium content did not correlate with fibre type but there was a positive relation with both noradrenaline content (r= 0·73;
P<0·05) and DNA content (r= 0·84; P<0·05). It is concluded that sympathectomy induces several biochemical changes in skeletal muscle which constitute a change and increase in fast myosin light chain synthesis and a corresponding fibre type transformation.
Clinical Physiology (Oxford, England) 1988 Apr; vol 8 (issue 2): pp 181-91
2.
The objective of this paper was to study the effect of sympathetic innervation on morphological and histochemical aspects of skeletal muscle tissue. Rabbit masseter muscle was studied using histochemical and immunohistochemical methods for periods of up to 18 months post-sympathectomy. The morphological and enzymatic characteristics of control masseter muscles were similar on both the left and right sides. The main features were muscle fibres with a mosaic pattern and a predominance of type IIa fibres, followed by type I. Type IIb fibres showed very low frequency. Sympathectomized animals showed varying degrees of metabolic and morphological alterations, especially 18 months after sympathectomy. The first five groups showed a higher frequency of type I fibres, whilst the oldest group showed a higher frequency of type IIb fibres. In the oldest group, a significant variation in fibre diameter was observed. Many fibres showed small diameter, atrophy, hypertrophy, splitting, and necrosis. Areas with fibrosis were observed. Thus cervical sympathectomy induced morphological alterations in the masseter muscles. These alterations were, in part, similar to both denervation and myopathy.
International Journal of Experimental Pathology
Volume 82, Issue 2, pages 123–128, April 2001
decrease of hyperhidrosis in the zones regulated by mental or emotional stimuli
European Journal of Cardio-Thoracic Surgery, Volume 36, Issue 2, August 2009, Pages 360-363
Recurrent sweating occurred in 17.6% of patients
http://thejns.org/doi/abs/10.3171/spi.2005.2.2.0151
Young woman dies after a 'routine' operation
Louise Field, 27, suffered severe brain damage when doctors accidentally punctured her lung and pumped gas into her stomach, the General Medical Council heard. She died two days later.
Mr Ormiston accidentally punctured her lung during the procedure, causing her oxygen levels to dip fatally. Dr Yanny allegedly failed to tackle the situation properly as the GMC hearing was told he “knew, or ought to have known” that brain damage was inevitable as he pumped Louise full of drugs to try to reverse the condition.
When the young Midland woman was rushed to another hospital, it was claimed Dr Yanny gave no indication she might have neurological problems – likely to have been caused due to a lack of oxygen.
He was also accused of failing to inform the specialist registrar at Hemel Hempstead General Hospital about drugs given, or even provide a simple anaesthetic chart.
Mr Ormiston admitted making inaccurate records after the operation and was slammed by the GMC panel for “significant departures from good medical practice”.
But he was still cleared of serious misconduct and it was decided that his fitness to practise was not impaired.
Dr Yanny managed to keep his job after offering a series of “undertakings”.
http://www.sundaymercury.net/news/midlands-news/2010/06/20/newport-parents-speak-about-tragic-loss-of-beautiful-daughter-66331-26685674/2/
results of ETS deteriorate and compensatory sweating does not improve with time
10-YEAR FOLLOW-UP OF ENDOSCOPIC THORACIC SYMPATHECTOMY
G. Somuncuoglu, T. Walles, V. Steger, S. Veit, G. Friedel
Schillerhoehe Hospital, Gerlingen, Germany
2008;7:147-200 Interact CardioVasc Thorac Surg
hand, which may become hyperkeratotic, with fissuring and scaling
The autonomic nervous system: an introduction to basic and clinical concepts
By Otto Appenzeller, Emilio OribePost-sympathectomy neuralgia: hypotheses on peripheral and central neuronal mechanisms
Post-sympathectomy neuralgia is proposed here to be a complex neuropathic and central deafferentation/reafferentation syndrome dependent on: (a) the transection, during sympathectomy, of paraspinal somatic and visceral afferent axons within the sympathetic trunk; (b) the subsequent cell death of many of the axotomized afferent neurons, resulting in central deafferentation; and (c) the persistent sensitization of spinal nociceptive neurons by painful conditions present prior to sympathectomy. Viscerosomatic convergence, collateral sprouting of afferents, and mechanisms associated with sympathetically maintained pain are all proposed to be important to the development of the syndrome.
Author Keywords: Deafferentation; Central sensitization; Viscero-somatic convergence; Ectopic discharge; Sympathetically maintained pain
Pain
Volume 64, Issue 1, January 1996, Pages 1-9
Ectopic discharge in injured nerves: comparison of trigeminal and somatic afferent
Brain Research
Volume 579, Issue 1, 1 May 1992, Pages 148-151